
Anyone even remotely familiar with the sports world is well aware of reports that former USC star Reggie Bush is at risk of having his Heisman Trophy taken away from him. The return of the Heisman would likely be related to NCAA violations that allegedly took place within the USC program during the time when Bush played for them. When asked about the issue on Wednesday, Bush said, "At this point, it's kind of out of my hands."
Bush would not confirm or deny whether he spoke with the Heisman Trophy Trust about losing the award. Executive Director Robert Whalen said that no decision has been made.
USC lost scholarships and was banned from post season play, after the NCAA determined that a long list of rules had been broken by the university and its coaching staff. Bush was among those found to have accepted what the NCAA defines as illegal gifts and financial support.
I am still a bit confused about what Reggie Bush's Heisman has to do with any of USC's NCAA violations. If the idea is that poor character would serve as their justification for stripping him of the award, then that point is certainly questionable. The truth is that if the character of the NCAA itself was being measured, they would fail almost every test. Thousands of critics across America have consistently questioned the NCAA's policies toward its athletes and accuse the organization of stripping players and their families of the right to earn a living from the billions they earn on the field.
The great Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. once said, " An individual who breaks a law that conscience tells him is unjust, and who willingly accepts the penalty of imprisonment in order to arouse the conscience of the community over its injustice, is in reality expressing the highest respect for the law."
While Reggie Bush is certainly not going to go to prison for violating a set of contrived policies created by the NCAA, the reality is that he is college athletics' version of the runaway slave. During slavery, men and women were punished severely for breaking the law by demanding their right to be compensated for their own labor.
Violating NCAA regulations could be considered to be one of the most ethical and just things a college athlete, coach or sports agent can do. Most of them understand that without Reggie Bush and his family, both USC and the NCAA would have lost out on millions of dollars in revenue, but instead of giving Reggie and his family the right to negotiate for a living wage like the rest of us in America, Congress allows the NCAA to violate the labor rights of athletes and their families by keeping those billions of dollars to themselves.
I mentioned in a prior article that I believe that all black athletes should boycott the Heisman trophy anyway. I'm not sure why we wait in line hoping that this piece of metal can validate us for what the world already knows that we can do. Seven out of the last 10 Heisman Trophy winners were white quarterbacks, and it's rare that black athletes get that chance to be the kind of golden boy that the NCAA markets well enough to be certified with the Heisman. Rather than sitting and waiting for the Heisman Trust to take away the award, perhaps Reggie Bush may want to consider just giving it back.
Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition and a Scholarship in Action Resident of the Institute for Black Public Policy. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here. 
Comments: (6)
Add a comment
By: mswll4 on 9/09/2010 4:05PM
DR BOWAT, You said BLACK ATHLETES should boycott the HEISMAN.BOWAT,this is not a race issue and i wonder are you a real DOCTOR.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: ernest on 9/10/2010 8:35AM
next time someone refers to these spoiled brat athletes as slaves i want to you slap them in the face with either Roots, Jubilee, the Harriet Jacobs Story or Escape From Slavery. Reggie Bush Cheated and Should lose the Heisman. he received $ that ordinary people would not have even been looked at for college. did Reggie have to choose between putting food on the table and buying books for class? no! did he have to juggle his time between working 40+ hours per week 10 hours studying and still take care of a home? no. did he have to sit up at night bone tired from a long hard day and still read 5 chapters and get up and make it into work on time? no. did he have to wake up abd kick the rooster out of bed and plow the fields feed the chickens and still go to school? no! so what makes him a slave????????
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: CB on 9/10/2010 4:34PM
Who offered this stuff to Reggie? Did the university go along with it? Don't hate the player, what about the coach? What the university and coaches gain? No, this is not about race. It is about revenue. The almight dollar. Everyone has their number. Can I find yours?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: rasfanta on 9/11/2010 3:49PM
Leave Reggie, alone. He is not in college anymore. Give it a rest. It's been going on too long. Once again, acting as if reggie is a purchased robot who checks his humanity and independence at the door when signing a "contract". I am sick and tired of this sanctity of the "contract". Nobody owns anybody.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: You Know Who on 9/12/2010 5:46PM
Athletic programs are for money,academcic programs are for money.Colleges and Universitys are for money. Money trumps all cards in the deck.Money is the objective in all projects,I am a retired engineer.Trophys are the white-mans,tokens of appreciation.Wake-up the rest is window dressing,good luck,we miss you, bullshit man.Cash talks,straight and face,keep your visa&mastercards.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Carlton E. Munroe on 9/14/2010 2:52PM
Why did they not take O J Simpsons trophy? Let he who is without sin cast the first stone. Hypocites beware. Curly!
Reply to this Comment | Report This